Share This Episode
Our American Stories Lee Habeeb Logo

The German Immigrant Who Became New York’s Queen of Thieves

Our American Stories / Lee Habeeb
The Truth Network Radio
November 5, 2026 3:02 am

The German Immigrant Who Became New York’s Queen of Thieves

Our American Stories / Lee Habeeb

00:00 / 00:00
On-Demand Podcasts NEW!

This broadcaster has 4992 podcast archives available on-demand.

Broadcaster's Links

Keep up-to-date with this broadcaster on social media and their website.


November 5, 2026 3:02 am

On this episode of Our American Stories, Frederica Mandelbaum arrived in New York from Germany in 1850 with her husband, infant daughter, and very little money. She began by selling lace door-to-door on the Lower East Side, but poverty and limited opportunities soon pushed the ambitious immigrant toward a very different kind of business: buying stolen goods and reselling them for a profit.Marguerite Fox, former New York Times obituary writer and author of The Talented Mrs. Mandelbaum, shares how Frederica built one of the most powerful criminal networks of Gilded Age New York before one tiny strip of stolen silk finally brought her empire crashing down. Support the show (https://www.ouramericanstories.com/donate)Support the show: https://www.ouramericanstories.com/donateSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:

This is an iHeart podcast. Guaranteed human. Liberty has never been just a word to we Americans. It has guided every one of our endeavors for the past two hundred and fifty years, and now it takes form in a new way. The twenty twenty six semi quincentennial coin and medal program from the United States Mint.

It celebrates the founding ideals that have long shaped our coinage. Available one year only, this historic collection features new coin designs, limited edition releases, and reissues. Shop new official. Coins at usmint.gov/semiq. That's usmint.gov/semiq.

Picture a for sale sign on your front yard. It's not the house being sold; it's you. Your name, phone number, address, how much you make. Data brokers sell it to anybody buying it. Scammers, insurance companies, you name it.

That's why you want Incogni. Go to incogni.com/lee for sixty percent off. That's i n c o g n i dot com slash lee incogni dot com slash lee incogni dot com slash lee incogni dot com slash lee. Ready to feel more energized and in control of your health? If you've tried diet and exercise but still aren't seeing the results you're looking for, it may be time to explore a different approach.

At orderlymeds dot com, you can connect with licensed medical providers through a simple virtual process, all from the comfort of home and. Find out if a GLP one treatment may be right for you. Learn more at orderlymeds dot com. That's orderlymeds dot com. Compounded medications are not FDA approved.

Eligibility determined by a licensed provider. Individual results may vary. See website for details. This is Hoda Kotb from Joy One Hundred One with Hoda Kotb. Every purchase is a financial decision, so it's worth asking, "What am I getting out of this?" If you're using the Chase Freedom Flex Card, you can maximize your cash back on things you need.

More ways to earn, more ways to get rewarded. Sign up for the Chase Freedom Flex Card. Learn more at chase.com/getflex. This is a paid collaboration with Chase Freedom Flex Cards issued by J.P. Morgan Chase Bank.

A member FDIC, subject to credit approval. Offers subject to change. Terms apply. Indeed sponsored jobs get you quality candidates when you need them most. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes.

Less stress, less time, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. And listeners of this show will get a seventy five dollars sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves. At Indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply.

Need to hire? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. This is Lee Habib, and this is our American Stories. Frederica Marm Mandelbaum was a German Jewish immigrant who rose from poverty to become one of the most powerful crime bosses in Gilded Age New York. She built a sophisticated network that bought and resold stolen goods, financed robberies, and cultivated connections with criminals, police, and politicians.

Her wealth and influence made her both a respectable philanthropist and a notorious underworld figure. Here to share the story of this forgotten figure in American history is Margalit Fox, a former New York Times obituary writer and the author of *The Talented Misses Mandelbaum*. Let's get into the story. A hundred forty years ago, on a hot July day in New York City in 1884, a group of Pinkerton detectives burst into a modest-looking haberdashery shop on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, and they needed to get into the safe. They demanded the keys from the shop owner, a towering fifty-nine-year-old woman, beautifully dressed in diamond earrings and a floor-length silk gown, named Frederica Mandelbaum.

And Mrs. Mandelbaum refused. No, she said in her German-accented English, "Just to think of such a thing." Undaunted, the Pinkerton detective summoned a blacksmith. He came with a hammer and chisel, started hacking away, and suddenly a pretty teenage girl runs in from the next room, Mrs. Mandelbaum's daughter Annie, and she says, "Stop!" She hands over the keys.

The one honest member of that family, the Pinkertons, unlock the safe, and what spills out but an Aladdin's cave—jewelry of every description: diamonds, rubies, emeralds, bracelets, cufflinks, necklaces. Earrings, a heap of gold watches and watch movements and cases, fine silverware. They'd never seen anything like it. Upstairs. In Mrs.

Mandelbaum's beautifully appointed bedroom, they found melting pots and scales for weighing gold and diamonds. Elsewhere, they found trunks full of fine silver, the most expensive cashmere shawls, bolts of expensive lace. Mrs. Mandelbaum. And an employee were promptly arrested, and with that, the Pinkertons managed to do what the New York police force had not done in twenty-five years: arrest the head of the biggest organized crime empire, not only in New York but in America.

And as Missus Mandelbaum. This upright widow, philanthropic synagogue goer, is being led away. One of the Pinkerton detectives kindly advises her. He says, "You are caught at last. The best thing you can do is to make a clean breast of things." And with that, the six-foot-tall Frederica Mandelbaum whirls and punches him in the face.

Friedrich Mendelbaum came to this country in steerage in 1850. Her people were poor Jewish peddlers and traders in Central Germany, and she married at 23, a poor peddler named Wolf Mendelbaum. The region was in the midst of an economic depression. As in Ireland, there was a potato famine, and Jewish life was particularly difficult. Jews were restricted as to the trades they could ply, and the regions in which they could live.

So, in eighteen fifty, Wolf and Friedrika Mandelbaum, with their infant daughter Bertha, made the long voyage under sail, more than six weeks, and they arrived. In the port of New York, they settled in a neighborhood of the Lower East Side that soon became known as Klein Deutschland, Little Germany. It was one of America's first important ethnic enclaves, and there, Jewish and Gentile neighbors alike could pass their days speaking their native language, dancing and drinking in beer halls, seeing German folk. Parades. It was very homy in that respect.

However, it was also full of poverty and privation in the tenements where Frederica lived with her young family. More than twenty families might be packed into a small, flimsy, shabby building. Workmen's cart horses would die and drop where they fell. Their carcasses mounded with swarming flies. Residential buildings were situated right next to industrial buildings like factories, warehouses, and slaughterhouses.

It was a very, very difficult place to live, and as the Mandelbeums quickly discovered, jobs for immigrants. Were severely limited. In her first years in New York, Frederica worked as a peddler, working in the streets, already masked with pushcarts and wagons, peddlers selling all kinds of wares. She sold lace door to door, but because she was smart. An ambitious and determined not to remain in poverty, realized she would have to do something different.

Now, what happened in that period if you were an immigrant and wanted to rise economically, wanted a better life? There were these few dangerous, ill-paying jobs in the world of so-called legitimate commerce. For men, there was another route, the so-called crooked ladder, which consisted of various kinds of underworld activity that offered, for better or worse, a way to support your family, a way to rise economically and in social status. For women, who, in desperate last resort or bold self determination, sought A criminal livelihood. There were only two choices: shoplifting, or prostitution.

Shoplifting was the bottom level of illicit commerce. There wasn't much money to be made, and for a proper married woman like Frederica Mandelbaum, prostitution was clearly out of the question.

So what was she going to do? She knew that she needed to expand her business, not only selling stuff but acquiring stuff through whatever channel, disguising it, and reselling it. In other words, becoming a receiver of stolen goods, also known as a fence. She apprenticed to two.

Well-known New York fences, and under their tutelage, she learned to appraise the value of the luxury goods like silk and sealskin and cashmere and lace that the city's newly emerging middle class was being taught to crave. And so, by about 1859, she was able to strike out on her own, receiving goods of dubious providence from small-time thieves and street scavengers, asking no questions, and selling the swag onward at a profit. Frederica Mabelbaum had become a fence. And you've been listening to Margalit Fox, author of *The Talented Mrs. Mandelbaum*.

Tell the story of *The Talented Mrs. Mandelbaum*, and my goodness, what talent she had, and what a sense of risk-taking and adventure she had. Coming to the United States with her husband and her baby in steerage, and being a peddler wasn't cutting it for her. The options for women at the time, when it came to criminality, well, there was shoplifting and there was prostitution. They're attracted.

What did was becoming what we now know as a fence, developing appraisal values and knowledge and a network to become, well, as we'll learn, one of the most powerful underworld bosses in New York City. When we come back, the rest of the story of the talented Mrs. Mandelbaum here on Our American Story. Liberty has never been just a word to we Americans. It has guided every one of our endeavors for the past two hundred and fifty years, and now it takes form in a new way.

The twenty twenty six semi quincentennial coin and medal program from the United States Mint. It celebrates the founding ideals that have long shaped our coinage. Available one year only, this historic collection features new coin designs, limited edition releases, and reissues. Shop new. Official coins at usmint.gov/semiq.

That's usmint.gov/semiq. Your home address is on the internet right now. Anyone can find it. Anyone—a stranger, a scammer, someone with a grudge, someone sitting in a car outside your house. I didn't believe it, so I typed my name into a people search site.

Seconds later, there it was: my home address, my cell number, my family members' names. All of it exposed for anyone who looked. That's why I use Incogni. Incogni sends requests to remove your personal information, including your home address, from hundreds of data brokers and people search sites automatically. It keeps sending them because these sites love to sneak your info back up.

You don't fill out a single form. You don't make a single call. Incogni has sent 344 removal requests for me, and there's a 30-day money-back guarantee. Think about who could. Be looking you up right this minute.

They can't harm you if they can't find you. Go to incogni.com/lee for sixty percent off. That's i-n-c-o-g-n-i dot com/lee. incogni.com/lee Looking for a new way to take control of your health? If diet, exercise, and willpower alone haven't gotten you where you want to be, visit OrderlyMeds.com to learn about GLP-1 treatment options.

With the convenient virtual process, you can connect with licensed medical providers from home and see if treatment may be appropriate for you. Visit OrderlyMeds.com today. That's OrderlyMeds.com. Compounded medications are not FDA approved. Eligibility determined by a licensed provider.

Results may vary. See website for details. This is Hoda Kotb from Joy One Hundred One with Hoda Kotb. Have you started your holiday shopping yet? This time of year always feels like the list just keeps growing: gifts for family, gifts for friends, stocking stuffers, plus all the everyday things you still have to buy, like groceries and gas.

That's why being a little strategic about the spending on gifts and those everyday needs is key. With the Chase Freedom Flex card, you can be a little savvier. Finding the right gift feels good, and maximizing cash back feels even better. Freedom Flex offers plenty of ways to earn more. You get 5% cash back on popular rotating quarterly categories, 3% on dining and drugstores, and 1% on all other purchases.

So while you're checking names off your holiday list, those gifts can be a treat for you too. This holiday season, let Freedom Flex reward you. More ways to earn, more ways to get rewarded. So sign up for the Chase Freedom Flex card. Learn more at chase.com/getflex.

This is a paid collaboration with Chase Freedom Flex. Cards issued by J.P. Morgan Chase Bank, and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval. Offer subject to change.

Terms apply. All right, quick quiz for the hiring managers out there. What's worse, being understaffed or being poorly staffed?

Well, that's a trick question because both are recipes for chaos. Either way, just say to yourself, "This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs." You'll get matched with candidates that meet the skills, certifications, and everything else you're looking for. Or go a different way and get no traction. Seriously, sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95 percent more likely to report a higher than non-sponsored jobs. It really is a no-brainer.

Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. And listeners of this show will get a seventy five dollars sponsored job credit to help your job get the premium status it deserves at Indeed dot com slash podcast. Just go to Indeed dot com slash podcast right now.

Indeed dot com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need to hire? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. And we return to our American stories, and to the story of crime boss and philanthropist Frederica Mandelbaum.

Let's get back into it. Here again is author Margalit Fox.

So, Frederica was smart. She knew that in order to go out on her own, she would need to expand the range of merchandise she had been offering as a peddler, and she would need to stock better stuff.

Well, without capital, how could she do that? She turned to the cohort of petty thieves and street scavengers that were forming an underground economic system in New York. She had the women shoplifting in the city's fine department stores by day.

Now the men breaking into docks, at warehouses and textile emporiums, stealing bolts of silk by night. And they brought them to Frederica. She disguised them, if necessary, so that they could be less readily identified by their owners, and she sold them onward at a profit. Frederica Mandelbaum was brilliant at putting her finger to the wind and seeing. What was in fashion, and therefore what the public wanted to buy at deep discount, so she knew she had to go for swag in a proper jewelry store, like Tiffany and Company, which was one of her first stomping grounds.

She would go in beautifully dressed. Look at the diamond counter, where in those days a lot of loose diamonds were sold that could later be set any way the owner wanted. She didn't buy anything, but she was getting a sense of the lay of the land of the store and what the staff was doing, who was where, and someone as elegantly dressed as she was by this time would have aroused no suspicion. She then. Worked out a method by which a very elegantly dressed pair of her thieves—first an elegant man, and following him by some minutes an elegant woman—could steal an enormous loose diamond from the diamond counter at Tiffany's using no other weapon.

Than a piece of chewing gum, a piece of chewed chewing gum, and I will leave what happened to the imagination. The whole modus operandi is explained in the book. Fridrika Mandelbaum, cautious as ever, starts small. In 1869, she floats a trial balloon. She underwrites.

Part of the expenses to buy a set of bank burglars' tools, and you know the equivalent of tens of thousands of dollars worth of tools in today's money, for a cohort of men to knock over the Ocean National Bank in Lower Manhattan. Possibly with Mrs. Mandelbaum's backing, they put up rent money to rent an office. In the basement level of the bank, that conveniently was under the office of the bank president, where the vault was. And using Mrs.

Mandelbaum's tools, they slowly chip away at the ceiling of their rental office until they're able to cut through the floor by night of the bank president's office. Go into the vault, and they go after paper, cash, and bonds. That operation is so successful that she bankrolls several more bank burglaries around the country, and this continues until her arrest in eighteen eighty four. The police of New York City were very much aware. Of Fridrika Mandelbaum and her crimes and how she earned her living, by the 1870s she was literally world famous.

She would be the subject of newspaper and magazine articles that would at least hint at her illicit enterprise.

Sometimes they would out and out call her the notorious fence of the Lower East Side, and two different stage plays had characters based on her. That was how famous she was. When she died, her death was covered in every major American newspaper, and as far away as London. And so let's just say. She made it very much worth the while of everyone, from the cop on the beat to some of the highest police officials in the upper echelons of the department, to let's say look the other way.

In. Eighteen eighty-four, a reformist DA, a man named Peter Olney, was appointed in New York, and he decided at long last that somebody should go after Mrs. Mandelbaum. Well, he knew he couldn't trust the police; they were her lapdogs.

So the new DA enlists the Pinkerton firm, and in the summer of 1884, the sting operation finally works. The agent who is undercover is able. To seize a tiny strip of marked silk and covertly puts it in his pocket, and that becomes Exhibit A in her pre-trial hearings after she is arrested. An irony of ironies, in the twenty-five years she operated, something like ten million dollars worth of stolen merchandise passed successfully. Through her shop, and that's ten million eighteen nineties dollars.

It would be something like three hundred million in today's money. But all it took in the end to bring her down was a single little strip of silk. She is arrested. The case comes to trial. The courtroom is packed with spectators.

The DA is there. Silk merchants are there with their exhibits to match the silk that was recovered in her shop. The clock strikes eleven. The court clerk calls, "Frederica Mandelbaum." There's silence. Julius Mandelbaum.

Silence. Hermann Stauder. Silence. They're all gone. They slip the jurisdiction, and now she has to flee not only the neighborhood and the city, but the country.

In 1894, she dies in Hamilton, Ontario, at the age of 69, and her coffin was brought back to New York, and she was buried in the family plot in Queens. Alongside her husband and daughter, and it is said that at her interment, some mourners who had known her professionally deftly picked the pockets of other mourners. And a special thanks to Margalit Fox, a former New York Times obituary writer and the author of *The Talented Misses Mandelbaum*, and what a story about a time period and how this particular lady became the greatest fence. In New York history, in the 19th century, at least, and my goodness, how she started—just seed capital to bank robbers, and ultimately wandering around the top retail spaces to see what's going on, to develop a sense of what the fashion world is moving and not moving, and then, of course, that new reformist DA who didn't want to put the police on her because, well, she owned the police.

So the Pinkerton stepped in. One scarf ended up being her undoing. The story of the talented Misses Mandelbaum here on Our American Stories. Grandparents, listen up. Your grandkids' home address could be online right now, exposed for any stranger to find.

Here's how: type your name into a People Search site. You'll see your home address, your phone number, and a list of your relatives. Click one name, and you could be looking at where your grandkids live, where they sleep at night. You lock your doors. You check the windows.

Incogni helps you lock the digital one. Incogni sends requests to remove your personal information, including your home address, from hundreds of data brokers and People Search sites automatically. It keeps sending them because these sites love to put your info back up. You don't lift a finger, no forms, no phone calls. Incogni has sent 344 removal requests for me, and there's a 30-day money-back guarantee.

You spent a lifetime protecting your family. Keep doing it, starting today. They can't harm you if they can't find you. Go to incogni.com/lee for 60% off. That's i-n-c-o-g-n-i.com/lee.

Cogni. dot com slash Lee. Liberty has never been just a word to we Americans. It has guided every one of our endeavors for the past 250 years, and now it takes form in a new way. The 2026 semi-quintennial coin and medal program from the United States Mint it celebrates the founding ideals that have long shaped our coinage.

Available one year only, this historic collection features new coin designs, limited edition releases, and reissues. Shop new official coins. At usmint.gov/semiq. That's usmint.gov/semiq. Ready to feel energized and in control again?

At Orderly Meds, we have helped thousands just like you take charge of their health with a GLP-1. If you've tried dieting, exercising, and relying on willpower, and nothing seems to stick, then it might be time to talk to a licensed provider about your options. That's what Orderly Meds is for. This fall, choose healthier habits for yourself with a visit to OrderlyMeds.com. You don't need to visit with a physician in person to become eligible.

Orderly Meds has a simple Virtual process. Connect with licensed medical professionals who can determine whether a GLP-1 treatment may be appropriate for you wherever you are. Get started from the comfort of home online. Change your habits and consider a new approach to feeling your best. Visit OrderlyMeds.

dot com to learn more. That's OrderlyMeds. dot com. OrderlyMeds. dot com.

Gain confidence and choose better habits this fall. Compounded medications are not FDA approved. Eligibility required and determined. A licensed provider. Individual results may vary.

See website for details. Wait, I came in for two things. How is this forty-seven dollars? All right, we're gonna need a plan here. Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking.

No overdraft admin fees. No monthly maintenance fee if you're under twenty-five. Oh, that's actually really simple. Safe Balance Banking. One less thing to figure out.

Learn more at bva. dot com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC. Deciding on what to listen to is hard.

Using Zumo to stream music from iHeart Nineties Radio is easy. Or play iHeart Country Classics Radio or Hip Hop Beats. Your choice, all for free. Stream easy with Zumo Play. Get live and on-demand entertainment with no logins, no signups, no accounts, no hassle.

Get cozy on the couch and binge your favorite movies like About Last Night, starring Kevin Hart, Panic Room, starring Jodie Foster, and more. All streaming free on Zumo Play. Go to play.zumo.com now. Life. Is hard.

Zumo is easy. Mattresses have been made of foam for a very long time, so have pool noodles. Purple thought your spine deserved a little more innovation. The patented Gel Flex Grid flexes to cushion pressure points, supports your spine, and pulls excess heat away. Gel for cooling, Flex for comfort, Grid for support.

Because waking up shouldn't require a recovery period. Better sleep starts with Purple. Visit purple.com or your local purple showroom and speak with a sleep genius today.

Get The Truth Mobile App and Listen to your Favorite Station Anytime