Share This Episode
Family Policy Matters NC Family Policy Logo

The Benefits of Debating the Declaration of Independence (with Tony Williams)

Family Policy Matters / NC Family Policy
The Truth Network Radio
November 16, 2026 12:20 pm

The Benefits of Debating the Declaration of Independence (with Tony Williams)

Family Policy Matters / NC Family Policy

00:00 / 00:00
On-Demand Podcasts NEW!

This broadcaster has 326 podcast archives available on-demand.

Broadcaster's Links

Keep up-to-date with this broadcaster on social media and their website.


November 16, 2026 12:20 pm

This week on Family Policy Matters, host Traci DeVette Griggs welcomes Tony Williams, a Senior Fellow at the Bill of Rights Institute and co-author of the book Divided Over the Declaration: How an Enduring Debate Sustains the Vision of America, to discuss why people are debating the Declaration of Independence and how that shapes our country today. 

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:

Welcome to Family Policy Matters, a weekly podcast and radio show produced by the North Carolina Family Policy Council. Hi, I'm John Rustin, president of Ency Family. In each week on Family Policy Matters, we welcome experts and policy leaders to discuss topics that impact faith and family here in North Carolina. Our prayer is that this program will help encourage and equip you to be a voice of persuasion for family values in your community, state, and nation. And now, here's the host of Family Policy Matters, Tracy De.

Bet Griggs, welcome to Family Policy Matters. As we celebrate our nation's 250th anniversary this year, many have wondered out loud if this grandest of experiments, the United States of America, is able to survive. We often think of Benjamin Franklin's famous warning as he left the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia: "We have a republic," he said, "if you can keep it." So, is it a threat to? America, that there seems to be so many different interpretations of the Declaration of Independence, which expresses many of the founding principles that underlie our very Constitution.

Well, there's a new book that tackles this question and actually makes the case that this constant grappling with the meaning of the Declaration is a good sign. Tony Williams is a senior fellow at the Bill of Rights Institute and co-author of Divided Over the Declaration. How conflicting views of the founding document shape America today? Tony Williams, welcome to Family Policy Matters.

Well, thank you so much for having me. All right, so tell me what inspired you and your co-author David Bob to write this book in the first place. After 35 years of studying history and civics and writing about it, teaching it, you know, I really found that there were just so many times, and especially key moments in American history, where Americans were debating important matters of foreign policy, of politics, social issues, and so forth, and the Declaration of Independence just always was at the very core of those debates, and so it seemed like a very dramatic story. Story to tell, and very interesting story to tell. And you know, once I dug around, found even more mentions of the Declaration, even in places I didn't really expect to find.

So that's what guided the book. And the celebration of America 250 was a great time to offer those stories to Americans to read about and to reflect about and discuss. Tell us about some of the contention. What are some of the ways that you see we commonly disagree over the interpretation of the Declaration of Independence?

Well. We certainly have during so many times in our nation's history, and we shouldn't be surprised by that, right? Because we debated the Declaration itself and the question of independence for months in the Second Continental Congress, and then we debated the question of independence and even the Declaration for a few days, and a lot of it was originally cut. And then from then on, we debated it, you know, and made claims on it, and so we have these rival interpretations and rival claims. Enslave people in New England.

England in the decades after the Declaration, we're making claims on freedom and won those claims. Right, they appealed to those natural rights. The women of Seneca Falls said all men and women are created equal, and not only Lincoln but John Quincy Adams and John Calhoun and Stephen Douglas, they were all debating questions of equality and the debate over slavery and its expansion, leading up to and including during the Civil War. And then it's certainly been a touchstone among politics and other.

Social issues, and Martin Luther King and John Lewis alluded to the Declaration significantly at the March on Washington.

So throughout American history, it's always been debated, and that's okay because the Declaration creates a government by the consent of the governed, right? And so that means that we're meant to debate, we're meant to deliberate together, we're we're meant to argue, we're meant to contend with each other and over those ideas. And out of that contention, out of that disagreement, out of that debate, we hope to. Consensus by listening to each other, by being moderate, by having a spirit of humility, we can come to some common understanding.

So the Declaration has been debated, but it's also the source of that debate. But we needn't fear it because it's a source, ultimately, of our greatest source of strength of unity.

So bring us up to the modern day. Then you mentioned a lot of historical references and ways that we argued. But what are some ways we're arguing today? And explain a little bit more about why you think that is actually a sign of of health and not necessarily demise.

Well, we're still debating the Declaration today, and and we had you know questions about the 1619 project five or six years ago. And did America begin in 1776? Did it begin in 1619? And we have had a whole host of other. Debates and and we've debated it during the current 250th celebration, right?

And people sort of got caught up in policy and who's the president and for and against and so forth. And so we see even in the celebration of America 250, even in our current discussions of how to understand the founding and the Declaration, we see a lot of debates. And that debate can be very healthy if we listen to each other, right? And if we seek common ground and we seek to understand. And we seek to really deliver over these principles.

Now we may have disagreement over the principles, even and what they mean and so forth. But that's okay because we've debated them and their contested meaning for 250 years.

So it doesn't scare me that we're doing that. We just need to do so productively. You started your book with the issue of slavery. Why did that represent a really good overview of the Declaration of Independence and its ability to maybe change the mind? Of the American people.

Well, we open with Frederick Douglass, actually, and he shows, even within his own thinking about it, how he changed his mind on the Declaration and how, in 1852, at this Rochester Ladies Abolition and Sewing Society, they later dropped the sewing part, but he delivered a speech to them, and he initially said, "It's your Declaration, it's your day of celebration, it's your vaunted." Freedom, but then he eventually also says it's not for me because me and my people have been and and are enslaved. Right at this time, he's free and he's an abolitionist, but you know millions of African Americans at that time are enslaved. But in the end, he says these are saving principles. These are the principles by which we can end slavery. These are the principles by which we can all live in a free society, enjoying our equal rights.

And many African Americans made claims on it from the enslaved. People in the North in the 1770s, 1780s, they issued freedom petitions and launched freedom suits for their freedom, and they won. They invariably won. It's an amazing story, and many white Americans recognized the contradiction of slavery and their principles of freedom and self-government. And so, there was a massive emancipation movement, gradual and outright, in the North, and there were also tens of thousands of private manumissions, but.

This debate continues because slavery obviously does not end until the Civil War, and so the debate over slavery and its expansion. I would say, of course, it included the Declaration because that is our core document. That's our creational document. It's an assertion of who we are as a people, and so in debating these very important and contentious issues of the day, they rightly look to the Declaration to understand, you know, their positions. Right.

Right. This is so fascinating to me because. I mean, you've made the point that once the declaration was written, it wasn't a done thing. I mean, like you said, the slavery took years. The suffrage movement for women took years.

Are there some issues even today that we could look at and go, you know what? You could stake a claim. You could make a change based on the Declaration of Independence that some people may or may not be thinking of. Everything, right? I mean, you know, the Declaration formed an important part of the debate over.

The Spanish-American War and the treaty afterwards, in terms of like, are we an empire? What are the purposes of our foreign policy? If we take over colonies or other countries, can they give their consent? You know, in our government, should they give their consent? You know, where they're on right now, and I have been with other countries recently, and you know, the Declaration needs to inform that we look at immigration issues and birthright citizenship and Christian nationalism and and all these various issues, and I won't get into all of them, but you know.

Know they should all be informed by the Declaration, right? But and and in many ways they're not, right? They touch the Declaration, but we're not arguing.

Well, right? We're not having the Declaration front and center and saying, well, what about questions of justice? What about questions of equality? What about questions of of self governance? All of these ideals of the Declaration, the natural rights, and so forth, republican government.

These are all principles that should, and I hope will. Continue for the next 250 years to animate our policy discussions about foreign policy, politics, social issues, etc.

So there's lots of issues that deal with it. I just don't know that we're allowing the declaration to really guide some productive conversations. You said we're not arguing well, and why is that? Do you think it's that it's inconvenient some of those truths in there, or do you feel like it's an ignorance? We're not familiar enough.

Yeah, I think it's all of those, but you know, I think that. When we start to see the other side as unpatriotic, when we start to see them as a quote existential threat to democracy and so forth, then we can't be moderate, right? And then we we're not humble in our own positions, and we don't try to seek consensus, we don't try to seek compromise, because compromise is sort of a surrender of position and of policy and of principle and so forth, and that is troubling. I don't think it's insurmountable, but it is troubling because. That is the very nature of our system—to debate, to talk to each other, to listen to each other.

Right? That's what makes Republican self-government possible. That's what makes democracy work. Right. Yeah, I'm impressed with a lot of the words that you keep throwing out here: seeking common ground, seeking understanding, humility.

These are not often words that come to mind when we listen to to people debating some of these very important issues.

So, how do we achieve that? You said you didn't think it was insurmountable, but how? How do we achieve that? How do we move toward a place where we stop considering people who disagree with us as somehow subhuman? America 250 gives us a good opportunity.

Whether we take advantage of it or not is a different question. But you know, it provides us because we're still celebrating America 250, right? And we will continue to do so as we think about the Constitution and the Revolution and all these great anniversaries. America 250 is still alive and well and should be for the next 250 years. And I think what we need to Do is see in the declaration our common principles.

I mean, we all believe in freedom. We all believe in equality. We all believe in natural rights. We all believe in self-government. And so, we need to see our common identity as Americans, right?

Because America is a place. It's also an idea, right? And we're also a people, right?

So, in consideration of those things, that it's a place where people and it's An idea. We need to see that we're all in this together, and that we all believe in these ideals. We can contest their meaning. We can debate them. But as I said, the Declaration lays down the principle of government by the consent of the governed.

That's all of us. And and the only way that that becomes possible and a working, feasible form of government and of civil society is that we talk to each other, and that we respect each other, and that we're moderate, and that we actually see that we're all in this together. You know, twenty years ago, we all recognized that we're in this together, and we all work together, even as we disagreed over politics and policy and so forth. But but we shared a certain identity, and so we need to recapture that and allow America 250 to the spirit of America 250 to sort of infuse us and to turn down the heat a little bit. We're heading into that holiday season, and that's the time when we generally gather together with family, whether we agree with them politically or any other way.

Of course, we hear this. Sad stories of people just completely cutting off parents or siblings because they don't believe the way they do. Can you talk to us a little bit about a perspective that we could take into those gatherings without just getting up in arms and and taking it on as a debate? How do we go about that? A lot of what I've been saying applies to your family even more so than even you know your neighbors and people in your community.

I mean, we love and cherish respect our families, and you know it's really Shocking to me that we're going to allow who we even think the other person voted for, or what news channel they like to listen to, for or against us, or so forth. You know, everything has become so politicized, right? Right down to our burritos and the cars we drive and and everything else.

So maybe it's not surprising it's intruded into our Thanksgiving occasions to get together. But we need to cherish family, and we need to again have that spirit of moderation and humility. That I just love this person. I want to be. Relationship with them, and you know who's president, whether I'm for against, doesn't really matter.

And try to overcome those boundaries and recognize that we're going to regret. You know, we don't want to have a life full of regrets. We want to, you know, love each other, and and especially in our families. We are about out of time, and I hate that because this is just really interesting. But people can go to your Bill of Rights Institute webpage.

You have so many books that you have written personally. Tell us where we can access all this great information. You know, I also have my author page at Amazon, of course, and there's also the Bill of Rights Institute .org, which has just a ton—not just my stuff, but just a ton of materials for teachers and for students on various topics in history and civics. Thank you so much, Tony Williams, senior fellow at the Bill of Rights Institute and co-author of the book we've been talking about today, divided over the Declaration, how conflict. Views of the founding document shape America today.

Thank you so much for joining us this week on Family Policy Matters. Thank you for listening to Family Policy Matters. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe to the show and leave us a review. To learn more about NC Family and the work we do to promote and preserve faith and family in North Carolina, visit our website at ncfamily.org. That's ncfamily.org.

And check us out on social media at ncfamilypolicy. Thanks, and may God bless you and your family.

Get The Truth Mobile App and Listen to your Favorite Station Anytime