This faith and finance podcast is underwritten in part by Movement Mortgage. Movement provides residential home loans and reverse mortgage options in all fifty states. Founded in two thousand eight during a major financial crisis, Movement was created to love, value, and serve people and communities. Learn more at faithfi. dot com slash movement.
Movement Mortgage LLC supports equal housing opportunity. NMLS number three nine one seven nine. For licensing information, visit NMLSConsumerAccess. dot org. Retirement may mark the end of a career, but it doesn't mark the end of our calling.
Hi, I'm Rob West. For many women, work, family, caregiving, and service have always been woven together in different seasons of life.
So perhaps retirement should be viewed less as an exit and more as a new opportunity to contribute. Jeff Haynan joins us today to explore a biblical vision for women, work, and retirement. And then it's on to your calls at eight hundred five two five seven thousand. This is Faith and Finance: Biblical Wisdom for Your Financial decisions.
Well, my good friend Jeff Haynan is a writer, entrepreneur, and founder of the Denver Institute for Faith and Work. He's also the author of "Working from the Inside Out: A Brief Guide to Inner Work That Transforms Our Outer World" and "An Uncommon Guide to Retirement: Finding God's Purpose for the Next Season of Life." Jeff, great to have you back. Thanks, Rob, for having me. Glad to be here. Jeff, you have a great article in our special women stewarding wealth issue of our Faithful Steward magazine, and you begin with a candid admission.
You say you've made the mistake of assuming the male experience of retirement is universal. Talk about that a bit more. What did you mean? Yeah, it's a good topic. You know, I think a lot of our thinking about retirement assumes a fairly traditional male career pattern: decades of continuous work followed by retirement.
But you know, I should have known better. I grew up with my mom and my sister and my wife, and women don't necessarily have the exact same overarching career path.
So, leaving a career for men oftentimes looks like a crisis of purpose, structure, meaning, because so much of identity has been tied to work. But for women, oftentimes it doesn't fully capture their experience. Women's careers are often much more intertwined with different seasons of raising a family and work bound together. Yeah, I think that's well said. And you describe those seasons as a spring of growth and a summer of care, and then an autumn of reinvention.
I love that. What do those seasons represent, and how do they tend to unfold in a woman's life? Yeah, well, the spring of growth often is in a woman's twenties, oftentimes early thirties. They involve education, launching of career, and sometimes a young family as well. And you see a lot of career development, professional growth.
The summer of care metaphor. Really, oftentimes happens in 30s and 40s when a lot of those careers may slow down, and the shift happens to some sort of version of either part-time work, no work, sometimes full-time work, but family responsibilities really rise to the surface. And then this autumn of reinvention oftentimes happens in 50s and 60s when women are moving back oftentimes into the work world to pursue new opportunities.
Sometimes having the not having been in the work world for a while.
So, this kind of relationship between family and work and how that influences retirement is pretty different, I found, for women than for men. Yeah, and that more fluid career path can have real financial implications over time. You refer to that as the woman's retirement gap.
So, what contributes to that gap, and how does it affect women as they approach retirement, Jeff? Yeah, women often retire with roughly thirty-five to forty percent. Less in savings than men, even though they tend to live five or six years longer.
So one major reason of that is lost compounding. Lower contributions, particularly during early and mid-career years, can have a significant effect decades later. And those lower contributions often they're not the result of poor financial choices. They just reflect years devoted to children, family, and other work that's oftentimes not compensated with money.
So the financial challenge is real, and it really is something that we should pay attention to. You're absolutely right, but you suggest that if we only focus on the financial gap, we can miss something equally important.
So, what else should we be paying attention to here? Yeah, I think as Christians, of course, we don't believe that work is the only vocation that we have. The only vocation isn't just paid employment. Of course, caring for our community, doing work, but also caring for our family is vocation. Work and family are both arenas where we live out our calling before God.
So, women, for instance, who move between professional work and caregiving and family responsibilities and new seasons of employment, they've oftentimes been living out that reality for decades. And men actually. Could learn a lot from that as they move into retirement as well.
So, women's experience may, I think, help us all think differently about retirement—not simply as leaving work, but as entering a new season of vocation in this broader sense. That's well said.
Well, after the break, we're going to continue to unpack this, and we'll talk about a biblical view of vocation and how that reshapes the way we think about retirement and what comes in that fourth quarter of life. We'll also talk about some. Incredible examples of women whose sense of purpose and calling continued well into their later life from Scripture. More just around the corner with Jeff Hanan. He's a writer, entrepreneur, and founder of the Denver Institute for Faith and Work.
He's also authored an article in our special edition of Faithful Stewart. Back with much more after this. Are you a financial professional looking to grow your practice while offering advice that aligns with your Christian values? By becoming a Certified Kingdom Advisor, you'll gain the biblical wisdom and professional credibility to serve clients who are seeking faith-based financial guidance. Each year, more than seventy-five thousand people search for a Certified Kingdom Advisor.
Join our community and share your expertise with clients looking for someone who shares their faith and values. Start your Journey today by going to kingdomadvisors. dot com slash get certified. Are you feeling overwhelmed by credit card debt? As followers of Christ, we are called to be good stewards of what God has given us.
That's why our trusted partner, Christian Credit Counselors, is here to help. Their debt management program can help you pay off your debt eighty percent faster while honoring your commitments in full. Take the first step toward financial freedom today. Visit Faith by. dot com slash CCC or call eight hundred five five seven one nine eight five.
Retirement may change the way we work, but it doesn't end our opportunity to serve. We're talking about rethinking women's retirement through vocation. My friend Jeff Haynan is here today. Jeff has authored an article that's in our new special edition of Faithful Steward around the theme of women stewarding wealth, and I think he just paints a beautiful picture of what this season can look like. Jeff, we started that before the break.
I want to talk about the word vocation. How does a biblical view of vocation reshape the way we think about retirement and what comes next? Yeah, it's a good question, Rob.
So, vocation and calling are uses the same word and they mean the same thing. They just mean living out our whole lives before the face of God.
So when we think about that in terms of retirement, it's not simply a financial event or distributing the assets over a lifetime or the point when a paycheck stops. Our roles may change over a lifetime, but our calling to serve God and our neighbor doesn't disappear.
So I think the better question for us in retirement might not be, "What am I retiring from?" But really, what is God calling me to in this next season of life, and what is that right combination? Between work and family, and caring for our churches and our communities. Yeah.
Now, Scripture gives us some beautiful examples of women whose sense of purpose and calling continued well into their later life, and I'd love for you to unpack a few of these. Yeah, Scripture has incredible examples for us.
So Sarah reminds us that it's never too late for God to begin a new chapter in someone's life. Naomi models extraordinary mentorship after a really profound loss, using her experience and wisdom to guide Ruth through a difficult cultural transition and difficult time in their nation's history. And Lydia and Deborah and Priscilla they show us women exercising professional leadership, and entrepreneurship, and ministry, and influence.
So when we think about women in the Bible. They remind us that meaningful contribution doesn't only belong to our middle or even our younger years, but they happen throughout a lifetime in a variety of ways. Yeah, you also point to the Proverbs thirty one woman as a compelling picture of vocation lived out over time. What stands out to you about the way she uses her gifts and influence?
Well, I think the first thing that stands out to me is how much even men ought to be paying attention to Proverbs thirty-one. Not only women, but it's an incredible picture of just a life well-lived.
So, in Proverbs thirty-one, she integrates many different roles rather than sort of dividing up her life into neat categories. She's living out this vocation of all life.
So, in Proverbs thirty-one sixteen, she's an investor, and yet in verse twenty-three, she's a wife. She's generous to the poor in verse twenty, and she cares for her household. You know, in verse fifteen, she's a businesswoman. In verse eighteen, and then a homemaker as well. In verse twenty-seven, her work, family life, generosity, leadership—they all belong into the same categories.
We're not talking about work-life balance per se, but they're all this faithful life of love for others and service to God. And I think you know something that I really like in Proverbs thirty-one, thirty-one. It tells us to honor her for what her hands have done, and let her works bring her praise at the city gate. And the city gate was a place. Of public influence, this is what we should be doing for women of all seasons of life, even women that are contributing well to our communities later in life as well.
There is no doubt about that. What a beautiful picture that is, Jeff. That raises an interesting question you ask in the article, and the question is this: Have we put so much emphasis on the financial benefits of retirement that we failed to honor women who continue to lead and contribute later in life? Yeah, financial preparation obviously is really important. It's a part of being a good steward, as we talk about.
Because retirement savings gap is real for women. There is a financial aspect of it, obviously. But if retirement only becomes accumulating enough money to stop contributing, then I think our vision of this vocation it's just too small. You know, many women reach later in life with decades of wisdom gained through difficulty, beautiful triumphs, work, family, hardship, caregiving. You know, leadership.
Service. I think that wisdom is enormously valuable to our families, our churches, our workplaces, younger generations, our communities. We should be looking at all ages, but women and men in later in life be looking for ways to contribute and to recognize and honor and put this wisdom to work over an entire lifetime. Yeah.
Now we don't want to minimize the real challenges that can come with aging. I mean, loss, health concerns, difficult transitions.
So, Jeff, how does our hope in Christ then shape the way we walk through those realities? Yeah, that's a good question. We do need to be realistic about aging and the body changing, and more trips to the doctor and physical decline. All these things are happening. But I also think Scripture is very realistic about this.
It talks about gray hair as almost being a crown and something good.
So we don't need to only go in the anti-aging world. We can age with grace and love, and it's an important thing for Christians to recognize. But also, I think Christians need to recognize that we are people of the resurrection.
So decline is actually not the whole story. George MacDonald, a writer who influenced C.S. Lewis, said that old age is not simply about decay or our bodies getting older, but it's a kind of ripening. It's a fresh life growing within, even as our bodies and our outer life change. And that gives us a different way to look at aging.
We can acknowledge what's being lost while still looking for what God may be bringing to maturity in us for the sake of the world. Hmm. Yeah.
Well said, Jeff. You ultimately encourage us to see retirement as a season of contribution rather than consumption. I love that. So, what might that look like in practical terms for a woman listening today who's about to enter this next season of life? In my book, I talk about: Is your entering into this season, oftentimes period of Sabbath and rest, can be the right move.
Like take some time to reflect and to rest and step back. It's important, but it also then begins by asking questions about her experience, her gifts, her relationships, the wisdom that can bless others, and what that actually might look like.
So it could be mentoring younger women in your life. It could be serving family. It could actually be contributing professionally in a new way or investing in your church community. It's going to look a little different for every woman. It's not idleness, and it's not only consumption.
I know what it doesn't look like, but I also think this rhythm of work and rest, or contribution and rest, happens over a period of a lifetime.
So retirement does not mean usefulness expired. Absolutely not. It can be a season when a lifetime of experience becomes a tremendous blessing to the next generation. Jeff, in your observation, have we, as the church, bought into the cultural narrative around retirement? Have we missed the biblical view?
Well, I think that's actually very much true. I think we have very much bought into that cultural narrative, and when work can be challenging, or contribution or serving others can be challenging, and the alternate is you don't have to, and we can live a life of self-focused pleasure. It's just like the road is leading that way for so many of us.
So it does take a self-conscious. Countercultural choice to say, what does it look like for me to love and to give? I think we actually need to think about that and what that looks like in our sixties, seventies, and even into our eighties. Yeah, and we come back to this beautiful picture that you referred to earlier of the city gate. We're not sitting on the front porch.
I mean, it's rest and renewal is okay, but it's this idea of leaning into the community and using our gifts and experiences and wisdom to pour into the next generation, right? Yeah, absolutely interesting. That biblical metaphor, that city gate—that's where public life happened, and there's a handful of references in scripture to elders at the city gate. It tended to be that the older people with wisdom and experience—they were the rulers. Cicero actually even talks about this, not even in the Bible, because they had so much to give.
And so it is a tragedy to say, "Hey, I hit a certain age and I'm stepping back from life and what my communities need." No, let's look at. Hey, this is a good opportunity to serve and to love. You know, it could be a city council, it could be work, it might be caring for grandkids. But these are all good ways Christians can show up to the world and to love our neighbors as ourselves.
So good, folks! Faithful stewardship in every season means asking how we can use experience, wisdom, resources for the glory of God and the good of others. Jeff, thanks for your time today, my friend. Always a pleasure, Rob. Thank you.
That's entrepreneur and author Jeff Hanen. Check out his article in the first ever special edition of Faithful Stuart Magazine. When you go to faithfy. dot com, and then pick up a copy of an uncommon guide to retirement: Finding God's Purpose for the Next Season of Life. It's my go to on this topic.
We'll be right back. We are grateful for support from Guidestone, whose diversified suite of investment solutions align with Christian values to create positive change in the world. More information is available at faithfy. dot com slash guidestone. Investing involves risk, including potential loss of principal.
Carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses of Guidestone Funds before investing. They are distributed by Foreside Funds Distributors LLC, which is not an advisor affiliate, a registered investment advisor, nor do they provide investment advice. We are grateful for support from Movement Mortgage, who provides residential home loans and reverse mortgage options in all fifty states. Guided by a mission to love and value people, Movement seeks to help individuals and families make informed financial decisions from buying a home to planning for retirement. More information is available at faithfy.com/slash movement.
Movement Mortgage LLC supports equal housing opportunity. NMLS number three nine one seven nine. For licensing information, visit. At NMLS ConsumerAccess.org.
Well, we're so thrilled to have you with us today on Faith and Finance because we believe this is a really important responsibility that you and I have been entrusted, and that is money management for the King of Kings.
So, if you have a question today, something happening in your financial life, we'd love to weigh in on it, help you understand God's word, God's heart as it relates to the decisions you're making in your financial life.
So, if you've got a question. Call right now. We've got some lines open. We'll dive into those questions here in just a moment. The number is eight hundred five two five seven thousand.
That's eight hundred five two five seven thousand. Whether you're giving, saving, or spending, whatever's going on in your financial life today, we would love to tackle it with you. Again, that number eight hundred five two five seven thousand. Let's go to Maryland. Hi, Hank.
Go ahead. Thanks, Rob. I have a question about donating a property to charity. What are the tax benefits? How are they received by the donor?
Yeah, has the property appreciated in value since you had it?
Well, it's an old house. It needs some work. I, you know, the neighborhood definitely has. Appreciated. I don't know.
Since my house has not been rehabbed, like a lot of theirs has. It's not maybe as much as they have experienced.
Okay.
So, yeah.
Okay.
Yeah.
So, I mean that that is potentially one of the biggest advantages, which may or may not affect you, which is that you avoid capital gains, because what happens is if you sell the property outright, then whatever appreciation you have, so the the selling price minus what you paid for it minus any improvements is the gain. And so, whatever that gain is, because you've owned it for more than a year, would. Generally, be you know at fifteen percent, maybe twenty percent, but by giving it first before you sell it, you don't recognize that capital gain, which means you get both the charitable income tax deduction for the market value as of the the you know the the date that you make the gift, and you avoid the capital gains on the appreciation.
So that's you know the real benefit in. In terms of the charitable income tax deduction, you know you would be eligible for a charitable deduction on your federal taxes.
So, you know you would, based on the value of the property, or if you wanted to give a percentage of it away, you could do that as well. I'd probably use a donor advised fund, but essentially you could, you know, take up to thirty percent of your AGI against your your taxes as a charitable contribution. And you know those are really the two primary benefits. It's I get the charitable deduction for the market value of the property when I make the gift that I can then use against my taxes. And if there's any gain, I avoid that by giving it before it's sold, which allows me to put more into the kingdom and then not have to pay those taxes.
So you could specify how much of a sale immediately will go to charity. Yeah, and and so what I would do there is use a donor advised fund. It's like a charitable checking account, essentially. I would set that up at the National Christian Foundation, and then what would happen is, and you could work with NCF on this or your closing agent. But you would essentially give a percentage of the property to your donor advised fund, and then at closing, whatever that percentage was that was given before the sale to the donor advised.
Fund would not come to you; it would go straight from the the closing agent into your donor advised fund. That portion would not be subject to capital gains. You would immediately get a a tax contribution receipt for that amount that hit the donor advised fund.
Now, at that moment, you've technically given the money away, which is how you can get the charitable receipt. And then, at any time when you're ready, you just log into the account and tell them where to send it. And as long as it's a five. A one C three charity. They'll send the check.
Oh, I see. Oh, very good. That clears up things for me and things I didn't know about.
So, I appreciate your answer. Then, absolutely, very much, absolutely, Hank. We appreciate your call today. God bless you. Let's go to Louisiana.
Hi, Mike. Go ahead. Hi. Um, I had a question. I've been hearing online and some of my family members saying that if you get a home equity line of credit.
The largest amount you can and you put into the home equity line of credit, you would be able to pay your home off faster, like five years, six years. Do you know anything about that? Yeah, so this is a program that a lot of people talk about, and essentially, you know, this is something I would just be really cautious about. A lot of people refer to this as something called velocity banking, and the claim is that it helps you pay off your mortgage much faster. And essentially, the basic idea is this: you open a HELOC, a home equity line of credit, using the equity in your home.
You take a lump sum.
So let's say you borrowed twenty or thirty thousand. You pay down the mortgage, and then you apply that money, you know, directly toward the the mortgage principal. And then you use extra monthly income to aggressively pay down the HELOC balance. And then you repeat the process over and over again. And once the HELOC is paid off, then you borrow again to make another large principal payment.
And the theory is by Making these large principal payments, you can reduce the mortgage balance and the amount of future interest charge by just kind of repeating this over and over again. The catch is you're not really eliminating the debt; you're moving the debt from your mortgage to your home equity line of credit. And you know most HELOCs have variable rates, which could be substantially higher than the rate on your existing mortgage. I mean, if you have a mortgage at you know three and a half percent. Or four percent, and you got your HELOC at seven.
You know, then you're potentially making paying more interest than less.
So, what I would prefer you to do, and and the other thing with that is, you've got to have a lot of of cash flow to keep all of that going. It's very complex and high risk. And if for some reason something were to go wrong and you lose your job, you could be in a you know a real difficult spot.
So, I think a better way would just be to simply make a. Additional principal payments every month.
So long as you have that margin, you've got to fully fund an emergency fund, and you know you're on track with other long-term savings, namely retirement. But for example, you know if you could afford to send you know two hundred fifty or five hundred dollars extra per month, that goes right to principal. I would much prefer you do that and try to save interest that. Way without the complexity, the added cost, and then just you know the ongoing upkeep related to the the velocity banking approach. Does that make sense, though?
Sounds so logical. I knew you would have an answer for me, and it's so much better just to pay extra on the principal. That's correct. Thank you so much. I love the show.
I love how you explain things to people. Folks who call in.
Well, bless you. Keep keep doing it. Thank you, Mike. I appreciate you, man. And thanks for calling.
Call anytime.
Well, folks, that's going to do it for us. We covered a lot of ground today. Let me finish with this. You know, when we think about a biblical worldview of money management, it starts with lordship. God owns it all, and then stew.
Money is a tool to accomplish God's purposes. I think right behind that is generosity. Giving breaks the grip of money over our lives. I hope you think about that today as you think about your role as a steward. A big thanks to my team today.
Couldn't do it without them. Autumn on phones, Devin, my producer, Jim on research, and everybody here at FaithFi. If you want to support our work, go to faithfi.com and click Give. We'll see you tomorrow. Bye bye.
Faith in finance is provided by FaithFi and listeners like you.