Game day is here, and with Instacart, you never have to miss a play for a snack run again. Get veggies, chips, dips, and drinks delivered right to your door, along with your groceries for the week. One order, everything you need from stores you know and love. Download the Instacart app and get delivery in as fast as thirty minutes. One of America's top true crime podcasts, Forty Eight Hours, is back with a new season.
Join us every Monday for a new episode and Tuesdays for a deep dive into that episode with postmortem. He said, "Quote, if they're going to die." I'm going to see them die. Plus, hear episodes from the 48 Hours archive Wednesdays and Thursdays. Follow and listen to 48 Hours wherever you get your podcasts, and subscribe to 48 Hours Plus on Apple Podcasts for ad-free listening. I'm Jane Pauley.
You're listening to an extended interview from the latest edition of Sunday Morning. All right, Billy. Thank you for being here. Thank you for traveling here. How are you feeling?
A little bit tired. Yeah, it's been a pretty crazy few weeks.
So this is your first ever real TV interview. Yeah. Why do it? Why do it now? You got to learn really painful lessons sometimes in life.
And with Elizabeth going through everything she did in the press, the lesson that was ingrained in us is you can't lose your voice.
So I look forward to speaking with you. Who is Billy Evans? You are looking at him. I am a father first and foremost. I've got two kids: my daughter Ivy's three, and my son Will's is five.
And I am a devoted partner to Liz. I am somebody who works really hard on the problems that I think need solving in this world. And for better, for worse, I am now in a documentary that a lot of people are seeing. A lot of people are seeing. Yeah, I mean, I had kind of the expectation that a lot of people would see it, but this has certainly exceeded expectations, and just kind of the enormity of it.
I think it's fair to say that you are the subject of what is now a cultural obsession. It's so strange. What is it like being one of the most recognizable people in America at this point? I don't like it at all. I would much prefer just to live a really quiet life, and I know it sounds silly to say that, considering we invited cameras into her home at this time.
I think one of the things that becomes apparent pretty quickly on in the film is that you're not just a very major, if not central, character. You are the villain, controlling, manipulative. Did you see it that way? I lived the experiences, and so my impression of the lived experience is very different than the edit. Like what I will say is that the filmmakers are incredible.
Like David Bolin, the DP, earns every ounce of credit for making that film so beautiful, and Nathan Lantz are incredible directors.
So you love them, you love the film, yeah. Even though it makes you into a villain, I would have preferred for that not to be the case. But it's entertainment. You know, are you okay being the subject of entertainment at your expense, which makes you truly look like a conniving, manipulative villain? I think that my goal is to have people see Elizabeth, and when I watch that movie, I see the person that I love in exactly who she is.
I'm curious to hear how you think that she was portrayed. I think that she's portrayed as somebody who's earnest. And who's naive at times, who's really smart, and who's incredibly caring and overly trusting, and those things are all true, but I think when you have a bit of, you know, insidious music or, or liberal. Cuts from one conversation to the next, stitching them together as if they're one. You can give a different impression, but I'm super biased.
Like I think she's the coolest person in the world.
So when I'm watching her on screen, you know, I cry when she says, "You know, the milk for ivy's in the fridge." Like I remember that moment like it's yesterday, and it's so strange to see some of the most vulnerable and painful moments in your life, then be. Put before the world, and I really admire her so much for having that vulnerability to welcome the cameras in and to say, "See me, judge me, make up your own mind." When people see the controlling Billy, they think of these scenes in the film. They think, "Yeah, you taking the eggs that are being scrambled, you taking over her ex account." Yes. With her agreement, yeah. But you are tweeting out expletive-filled comments, which is something that she would likely not do, using her AI, her name.
Yeah, the AI thing is really ridiculous to me. Talk about the X account. I mean, Elizabeth would likely not be dropping f bombs on X. No. In her no, she wouldn't.
Right. Yeah. So why would you do it?
So, can I give you the background of how we got into the ex account and kind of the sure process got started? I don't need, yeah, you can go for it. But the power of attorney and all that, yeah.
So, the way in which this process worked is Liz was unable to speak publicly for a long time, and the judge had said this is going to play out in the courtroom and not in the media. And upon losing the appeal, her and I had many conversations about speaking publicly, and we had collectively decided over the course of maybe two, three months that we were going to do so on X. And when we started, none of the stuff that you're describing was happening. But what ended up happening is, time and time again, people would say, "When are you launching your OnlyFans? When are you going to be launching a crypto token?" and Do I wish I would have handled it differently?
Absolutely, but it's that protective nature in me to protect her, and I think inadvertently, you know, it would make her look bad at times. And from the very beginning, in which we launched her X account, if you look at the bio, it says mostly my words posted by others, and there would be we would I would joke on it, saying sorry that was my intern, and you know this is X, this is not. You know, sworn statement in court or something. It was for sure. Yeah, but these are your words, not in her tone.
Yeah, and it's one thing when, as you said, you you take excerpts from her emails to you and put them on X. Yeah, totally understand. Or conversations that we had in person. I understand that, and she has given you permission. But when you are dropping f bombs, when it seems like you might be using her AI or preparing to in some way, I think it's easy to see why that gives other people the impression that you might be.
Overly controlling. Yeah, but I think it's important to know that this is like with her explicit permission. This is something that we described, and I would describe the things that I would say. And would she always be happy about them? No.
But the internet's a vicious place. Doesn't mean you have to play into it. No, but I'm not very good at this. Have you spoken to Nathan Fielder since the movie came out? Since the firm film first premiered, briefly, but.
Or the day that the before after you saw it, before. Have you spoken to them since you've seen it? I haven't. No. Why not?
Oh gosh, that's. I think they're probably worried I'm going to sue them. Are you? I have no intention to. No.
Why not? Because maybe I'm a different person than most people think I am. As you can tell, I'm somebody who's pretty. Willing to admit things on camera and to be seen, regardless of whether or not people like that.
So, if that was the case, I would be very willing to admit that. But it wasn't. And you really can see everything. Did you know you were doing the full Monty? Did you give permission for that?
Because there seems to be some discrepancy. Yeah, I would say that her recollections are pretty different on that. I did not. Give consent to do that.
Now, did I know they were filming me in the shower? Yes, but we would film 16 hours a day. Like all sorts of things were filmed with assurances made. I was just as surprised as the rest of the country to have my whole body on camera for the world to see, and it's been an awkward experience in having like your kids' teachers see that. It's really uncomfortable.
I mean, the one thing that struck me as someone who interviews people for a living is how physically close Nathan Fielder got to Elizabeth when he was speaking with her. Was that something that you were aware of at the time? I mean, it is uncomfortably close for me. Yeah, it was very different in person than with the lenses that they're using. It was not.
Like this, it was like this. That moment, he's leaning towards her on the couch. One at times, he'd be whispering or something.
So it didn't seem awkward or cringy. There were some awkward things that happened every single day. The film's production company, A24, said everything they filmed was with consent. What's inappropriate that happened? Requests to film things that are not appropriate for television, such as you in bed.
With Elizabeth, all sorts of things that the details I'd rather spare the audience. But no, I mean I think it's you become what they were asking. They were asking for everything for everything day and night time activity. Yes, and when you become close with a filmmaker, and you are trusting in their in their story. And you're saying, look, we really do want you guys to see everything, but there's a few lines we need to draw here.
Do you think that Nathan Fielder is infatuated with your wife? Maybe in love. I think a lot of a lot of people are infatuated with Elizabeth Holmes. But this seemed. More romantically leaning than I think you're taking things maybe too literally.
No, I don't think I am. I think that's pretty much everybody came away from that film thinking that he's either in love with her or has extraordinarily strong feelings. That seem to be romantic. I think Nathan cares a lot about Elizabeth, and I didn't get the impression for a minute that it was romantic. I think he cares a lot about her.
Come on. The scene at the end, where they're frolicking in the water, he's holding her hand to the right of them, also in the water. In some ways, this is a love poem to her. That's an interesting idea. I haven't thought about that, but so okay, you did not get the impression that he was in love with her.
I got the impression at the very least, infatuated. No, not in real life.
Okay, but from the movie, from the film, I think that there are bits that are played up to to criticize his own bias. What about?
Okay, hold on, that's that's interesting. What do you mean to criticize his own bias? This is a film about what can you trust, and throughout the film. We're asked to trust lots of different people, and then it calls into question who we can trust. And at the end, nothing is clear.
Nobody's love, nobody's.
Well, I think our love is completely vindicated in the end. I think so too. You know, I sit down, and Nathan's asking, like, "What would Liz say if she was here with you right now?" And I said she'd say that she'd spend her life building monuments of love to me, and I look insane. And then Nathan goes to visit her, and she says that verbatim. Two years later, he hadn't seen us together.
Insane, or maybe indoctrinated. It depends how you see the portrayal in the film, or totally wildly in love and connected, which is how I see it in my life. I think at the end, the last shot of you two sitting down together in the prison yard, yeah, does end the film. Giving the audience the impression this is a loving family for whatever else is going on. Yeah, we've got an incredibly loving family.
There's a lot of things that weren't seen on camera between the two hours that Amanda arrived at my house and the cut to that scene at the dinner table. And in watching the film, I think it was clear that there's an agenda there that I was not privy to. And I think that there was things that her trying to capture on camera. That she wanted to break you up. That she called you batshit crazy.
Yeah, I mean, batshit crazy thing—that's her opinion. But break me up—that's something I really don't like. I don't like hearing that.
Sounds like I don't know the circumstances of what she was going through in her life at that time. It sounds like there's a lot, and so you do know the circumstances of what was. It sounds like, from what other people have said, I don't know. I don't know. Look, it would be really unfair for me to say like, "How dare she judge my relationship?" and then for me to do the same.
So, I don't know. But I was certainly frustrated. I was certainly angry. I'm certainly embarrassed by saying things that. I don't feel today.
So you don't feel that there's vengeance in your heart, or that you want to ruin everyone. No, no. I was pretty angry in that moment. I don't feel that way. We'll have more from our Sunday morning extended interview after this break.
Discover top-rated stays loved by guests, rated highest by real guests through authentic reviews. Verbo, book a vacation rental loved by guests. I'm Kevin Roose, and I'm Casey Newton, and together we've been tech journalists for decades.
Now we're your hosts of Machine Gods, a new podcast from NPR that makes sense of what AI means for your work, your life, and all of our futures. Twice a week, we'll be exploring the biggest moves in tech and give you unmatched access to the real titans of industry. Listen to Machine Gods from NPR on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. What did you think about her role in this film? I'm really glad that they included her because it shows what a difference there is between the real thing and how eager she was to play a character.
Would you say that she played Elizabeth well? I'm glad Nathan was there to help her. Doesn't seem like you hold very high opinion of her acting. No, or of her as a person. You know, it'd be one thing if you had millions of dollars in the bank right now because of this film, which is obviously massively successful, and likely you would have had a lot to gain if you had taken a profit share.
Yeah, a lot, like a lot. The number is pretty silly. Yeah, I would imagine many millions of dollars. Like tens. Tens of millions of dollars.
Why would you give that up? You know, I don't know how much I can talk about it, but what I can say is, knowing where the money's going, I'm not unhappy about that decision. Meaning that the money is not going to the filmmakers. Not. That's all.
Like that's all I can say about it. Let's.
Well, so the opposite of that is: Are the filmmakers getting 100 of the profit? You just basically said no. If it's not going to you, and it's not, unless you're happy that they're getting all the profit, but you may be. Still, why not take the money? They said your wife is in prison.
She owes hundreds of millions of dollars in restitution. You're bringing up two children alone in a state where you have no contacts. Yeah. You need money. Yeah.
And I work for myself, not paying myself much at all. And I've spent a lot of my resources trying to defend my wife and to free her, and paying for childcare because I'm a single single dad. The lawyers, like the amount of money spent on lawyers, would blow your mind. Yeah, I mean that's why I thought it was a reasonable ask. And so, what caused you to change your mind?
Was it just the filmmakers browbeating you? I think that's a part of it. I think the disappointing thing is that giving giving it up was to demonstrate that this was not about the money. This was about people seeing Liz. But then they make it about the money.
Never cashed in on any of her Theranos anything. She never sold a single share. She gave up fifty million dollars of directors and officers insurance to help save the business. I mean, she never profited. She paid herself a salary, but beyond that, she didn't take a sick day for sixteen years.
Like she dedicated her whole life to that business. Do you regret not accepting your share of the profits? Like I said, knowing what I know, I do not. Even now, knowing what would it be nice to have that amount of money? Would it be super useful to be able to give my kids tens of millions of dollars?
We're talking about life changing. Safe, yeah. I mean, it's it's a crazy amount of money. Yeah, it would be nice to have, absolutely. But I can't look back.
You know, people can disagree about her guilt or innocence, and I think the film leaves a lot of questions there. About her intention and what she believes, but I find it hard-pressed for people to believe that her sentence is fair—that eleven and a half years for wire fraud, in which the courts and the prosecutors acknowledge that nobody was financially harmed, that there's no financial hardship from that loss, regardless of whether or not you believe in her guilt or innocence. Her sentence is insane. Eleven and a half years is more time than some people get for murder. And she spent how much of that time in prison, or will have by August 27?
Yeah, she will have spent about four years, a little over four years. But people forget that incarceration does not end when you leave prison, because then you move to a halfway house. And I've spoken to a lot of people at halfway houses to understand this process, and they said prison was better. How long is she in a halfway house for? It depends, and you're there for maybe a year, maybe two, maybe three, and then you go home, and then you're on house arrest.
And when you're on house arrest, if you violate any small thing associated with the conditions of your release, you can be sent back to prison.
So it's not like you're free in any way, shape, or form. It's a, you know, I've gotten to know a lot of the women. In the prison, on our weekend visits, and their families, and the guys kind of become close, and some of them have already gotten out.
So I've been able to learn from them what their experience has been like, which is the experience that we're about to. To hopefully have, which is reuniting with a family and the challenges associated with that, and the difficulties of their wife's not being able to sleep because they have to be up for count four times a night, and every time they hear the jangle of keys on a keyring, for their friend, they're worried that it's a guard. That they have PTSD and nightmares. Like I'm worried about those things. I'm worried about them a lot.
You're taken from everything that you love, and. That experience hurts, and it changes you. And I've—I'm just—I so admire Liz's strength. I guess she's gone through this. She is stronger.
She is more clear-headed than she has ever been. She is not scared. She is like anti-fragile. Um. But there's going to be a lot for us to work through as a family.
Like my kids. They don't know what it's like to wake up and go downstairs, and their mom's making them breakfast. Like even the good things are going to be different and weird. What do you tell them when you go to prison? What do you tell them?
Where mommy? It's changed over time.
So the first, when we first went there, my daughter was three months old. And my son was 21 years old.
So, what can you even tell them? You know, they're so little. But we have one really simple rule with our kids, which is if they ask us a question, we tell them the truth, regardless of how painful it is. We make it age appropriate, and we also tell them only ask questions that you want the answers to.
So you can't tell a three-year-old to ask questions only to the things you want an answer to. You haven't met my trust. You have not met my three-year-old. You have not met my three-year-old. I never stop.
He is Will's. He's a different breed. You know his mom is pretty unique. He's a different breed. Does it hurt you to have them have to see their mother in prison?
That that's essentially the only way they know their mother. It's become strangely normal. Like I don't, I hate it. I absolutely hate that my daughter's first steps were in federal prison. I hate that.
Your daughter's first steps were in federal prison. Yeah. But it doesn't mean that we can't find joy as we experience this. And our job to them is not to talk about how much it hurts and how painful it is, but to find the joy in seeing how many acorns we can collect in the prison yard and fit in a water bottle. It's finding, you know, the small little games that we can play to make each time we go to the same place every weekend.
Feel like you're going to Disneyland, and she is so wildly creative and loving towards them that when we're there, we have a great time. And although our time is limited when we are together, there's no phones, there's no distractions. It's just us and them, completely locked in for six hours, just. It's all about them, and now we have to find the time to talk personally. But that's one of the challenges, is I think there's not nearly enough time for us to have any intimacy, even verbal, even holding hands.
You know, we can't hold hands inside, so we can only hold hands outside.
Sometimes the kids don't want to go outside, so even that is taken from us. You know, I get to kiss her one time when I get there for like like a peck, and one time when I leave. And one hug when I get there, and one hug when I leave, and that is the extent of the time in which we get together.
So, how many days has she been in prison? I used to count every one, and then it just kind of became too painful. But it was—it's been since May thirtieth of twenty twenty-three.
So, like I don't know, fourteen hundred or something. And thirteen hundred.
So it's a lot of days. And so that's the only. Intimate affection that you've had since then. Yeah, it's a long time. I miss her so much.
You know, I talked to her right before I came in here, and I told her I said I'm kind of nervous, and she said, "Just be zen, enjoy it, embody love." I'll talk to you when you're done. I'm Jane Pauley. Thank you for listening. And for more of our extended interviews, follow and listen to Sunday Morning on the free Odyssey app or wherever you get your podcasts. Need a break?
Forget it! I quit. Escape to Pluto TV. This is objectively fantastic. Watch Tommy Boy, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Wayne's World, and more.
We're not worthy. The best things on TV really are free. Pluto TV. Stream now. Pay never.
This November, Yellowjackets returns for the final season. The Waskayai Yellowjackets have been found after 19 months in the wilderness. The girls may have been rescued, but homecoming is savage. No, no, no! I have to stay in control of the story.
You went behind my back. We weren't supposed to leave. Stream the final season of Yellowjackets November 20th on Paramount Plus. We're gonna be so totally fucked.